Supreme Court find A&E receptionist negligent in brain damage case

17th October 2018

Written by Jennifer Hales, solicitor in the medical negligence department at Fletchers

Michael Darnley v Croydon Health Services NHS Trust:  Organisations can now be held liable for the actions of non-medical staff, if misleading information is provided which causes injury.

In May 2010 Mr Darnley attended the A&E department of Croydon Health Services NHS Trust with a head injury. he should have been told that he would be assessed by a triage Nurse within 30 minutes. Mr Darnley was however incorrectly told by reception staff that he could wait up to 4-5 hours for medical treatment.

On the basis of the information provided by the reception staff, Mr Darnley decided to go home after 19 minutes.

At home, Mr Darnley’s condition deteriorated and by the time he had been readmitted to hospital he had suffered permanent brain damage.

It was alleged by Mr Darnley that if the reception staff had provided the correct advice (assessment within 30 minutes) he would have remained in hospital and received treatment thus avoiding permanent brain damage.

The High Court and Court of Appeal initially dismissed Mr Darnley’s claim on the basis that the Hospital Trust and reception staff did not have a duty of care to provide Mr Darnley with the appropriate waiting times.

Lord Justice Jackson in particular argued that to hold the reception staff responsible would open the floodgates and that Litigation about who said what to whom in A&E waiting rooms could become a fertile area for claimants and their representatives.”

NHS Resolution also commented that although this was a ‘sad case’ the ‘novel’ claim was resisted in the interests of the NHS, and that ‘opening up receptionists to negligence claims of this kind would have had very serious consequences’.

However, the recent ruling by the Supreme Court has overturned the previous judgements. The Supreme Court set out that it is well established that healthcare providers owe a duty of care to their patients and this includes the actions of Reception staff. There is no distinction between medical and non-medical staff.

The effect of the judgement is that organisations can now be held liable for the actions of non-medical staff. In the case of Mr Darnley, the misleading information provided regarding A&E waiting times caused him to suffer brain damage and long-term disability (for which Croydon Health Services NHS Trust will now have to compensate him).

This decision has implications for all healthcare providers, including GP, Dental receptionists, A&E and Ambulance services where employed non-medical staff provide advice on which patients rely.

Organisations must now take steps to ensure that non-medical staff understand the implications of their actions and that they have a duty to provide reasonably accurate and non-misleading advice.

 

Categories

Archives

Further Reading…

Take the first step now, you have nothing to lose

  • Top Ranked Leading Individual - Chambers UK 2016
  • The Sunday Times Top 100 - Best Companies To Work For 2016
  • The Lawyer UK200 - Listed Firm 2015
  • The Law Society - Clinical Negligence
  • The Legal 500 - Leading Firm 2015
  • The Investors In People Awards 2016 - Winner
  • Lexcel - Excellence in Legal Practice Management and Client Care
  • IIP - Investors in People
  • sia - Spinal Injuries Association
  • MASS - Motor Accident Solicitors Society
  • Apil - Association of Personal Injury Lawyers
  • Headway - The Brain Injury Association
  • avma - Action Against Medical Accidents
  • Backup Trust - Transforming Lives After Spinal Cord Injury
  • Child Brain Injury Trust
  • Cyber Essentials
Any Questions?

We know that making a claim can raise a few questions, here are some of the ones we get asked most often.

Read our FAQs

Contact Details
Phone
03300 080 321
Email
enquiry@fs.co.uk
Southport
Dukes House, 34 Hoghton Street, Southport, PR9 0PU
Manchester
St James's Tower, 7 Charlotte Street, Manchester, M1 4DZ
Map of the UK