What price to sign a liver?

15th January 2018

A liver surgeon who branded his initials on the livers of two patients has been recently received a £10,000 fine and been sentenced to 12 months community order, following his sentencing at Birmingham Crown Court on two counts of assault by beating. More significant charges of assault occasioning actual bodily harm were dropped.

Mr Bramhall was once considered a well-respected surgeon, known for his meticulous work in the operating theatre. However, he decided to sign his initial onto the livers of two donor livers, using an argon beam machine, before they were transplanted into their patients. The actions only came to light when the transplants failed for unconnected reasons and the explanting surgeon noticed the markings.

The Court appears to have accepted that Mr Bramhall did not intend any significant consequences from his actions but was critical of his childish arrogance in marking the livers in the first place. It recognised that his victims had been traumatized by the knowledge and felt that their trust had been violated.

It is likely that civil proceedings will now follow for at least the two patients involved in the criminal case.  However, it will be a concern for his other patients, that Mr Bramhall stated “this is what I do” when the signature was noted for the first time by one of the nurses.

Could this mean that every patient of Mr Bramhall will have a claim against the Trust for the psychological harm caused by now being forced to suspect that they too have an organ branded by Mr Bramhall inside them? Potentially, yes. The value of the compensation for such harm is likely to be modest, and it is unlikely that surgeons would ever perform a laparoscopy solely to examine the internal organs to be sure. However, it is not a huge leap to envisage a particular patient feeling desperate enough to want to know and for there be a psychological justification for such an investigation.  In the alternative, would an MRI or Ultrasound scan be sensitive enough to see any branding?

It would be expected for the hospital to have rigorously examined Mr Bramhall’s patient records and to be considering making unilateral without prejudice offers to his transplant patients. If this is what he does, the list could be very long indeed…

Categories

Archives

Further Reading…

The duty of candour – slow and steady progression

23rd October 2018

By Andy Tindall, Litigation Executive in the Medical Negligence team After the publication of AVMA’s report on the inspection and regulation of the duty of candour earlier this month, the…

A day in the life of a trainee solicitor

23rd October 2018

By Chloe Westwell, trainee solicitor No two days are ever the same at Fletchers Solicitors. Currently, I am working in the Litigation Team in the Clinical Negligence Department which is…

You don't have to go through this alone - take the first step now

  • IIP - Investors in People
  • The Sunday Times Top 100 - Best Companies To Work For 2016
  • The Investors In People Awards 2016 - Winner
  • The Legal 500 - Leading Firm 2015
  • The Law Society - Clinical Negligence
  • The Lawyer UK200 - Listed Firm 2015
  • Top Ranked Leading Individual - Chambers UK 2019
    Any Questions?

    We know that making a claim can raise a few questions, here are some of the ones we get asked most often.

    Read our FAQs

    Contact Details
    Phone
    03300 080 321
    Email
    enquiry@fs.co.uk
    Southport
    Dukes House, 34 Hoghton Street, Southport, PR9 0PU
    Manchester
    St James's Tower, 7 Charlotte Street, Manchester, M1 4DZ
    Map of the UK