Skip to main content
BIRTH INJURY

Why do families keep hearing the same concerns from maternity investigations?

Maternity reviews over the past two decades have flagged the same problems again and again, from poor communication to delays in acting on warning signs. If you've noticed this, you may be asking why nothing seems to change. We explain why, and what it could mean if your baby was harmed during birth.

This guide explains:

  • Why similar findings appear across different maternity investigations
  • What recent maternity reviews have identified
  • The difference between learning lessons and implementing change
  • Why families continue to raise similar concerns
  • What this means if your family has been affected by maternity care
  • How our solicitors assess whether care fell below the standard expected

Why are families hearing the same concerns?

Many families who read about maternity investigations are struck by how familiar the findings appear. Whether the review relates to one hospital, one trust or maternity services more broadly, similar concerns are often revealed. 

 Reviews have repeatedly found the same problems in how teams work together, such as poor communication. They have also found the same problems in patient care, such as missing signs that a mother or baby is getting worse, or not listening to mothers  and not escalating concerns quickly enough. These themes have appeared in major investigations over many years, including the Morecambe Bay review .Ockenden Review, the East Kent maternity investigation and Care Quality Commission’s National Review of Maternity Services in England 2022-2024, published in September 2024, which found that many of the same safety and quality concerns were present across NHS maternity services nationwide. For families affected by birth injury, this can raise difficult questions.  

Key information

Facts and highlights

  • Recurring themes about how teams work and patient care
  • Multiple investigations National and local reviews have identified similar issues
  • Implementation challenge of fixes to these issues

What have recent maternity reviews found?

Over the last two decades, several major maternity investigations have examined care provided to women, babies and families. While each review looked at different services and different circumstances, many of the findings have been consistent. Reviews have identified concerns around: 

  • Delays in recognising risk 
  • Delays in escalating concerns 
  • Failures in communication 
  • Inadequate monitoring of mothers and babies 
  • Poor teamwork between staff 
  • Families feeling that their concerns were not heard 

The Ockenden Review concluded that maternity services at Shrewsbury and Telford repeatedly failed to learn and improve. Similarly, the East Kent investigation found recurring concerns around clinical care, compassion, teamwork and responding appropriately to warning signs. 

Delays in escalating concerns and missed warning signs are the kind of issues our solicitors look at when we assess a birth injury claim. We ask three questions: did the healthcare team owe you a duty of care, did the care fall below the standard a reasonably competent professional would provide, and did that cause your baby’s injury? 

Why do the same issues keep appearing?

This difference between knowing what needs to improve and seeing those improvements consistently happen in practice is sometimes referred to as an “implementation gap”. The challenge in this process is that identifying lessons and making recommendations doesn’t automatically lead to lasting change. Improvements need to be embedded into everyday practice in every Trust region where maternity services are provided. This can be supported by: 

  • Training  
  • Adequate staffing 
  • Adequate support  
  • Leadership  
  • A culture where concerns are recognised and acted on consistently. 

 

National reviews, NHS data, maternity investigations and expert discussion from across the sector highlights a potential implementation gap, where concerns are identified and recommendations are made, but lasting change can be difficult to achieve across a complex healthcare system.  

This doesn’t mean that maternity services are not improving. Many professionals work tirelessly to provide safe care every day. However, investigations continue to suggest that some longstanding safety concerns are still being found. 

For families, this can be particularly difficult to understand. You may see the same concerns highlighted in different maternity reviews years apart and wonder why they continue to appear. While each investigation involves different circumstances, many point to the same challenge: turning lessons identified into lessons learned and sustained over time.

Questions families often ask

If your child suffered a birth injury, seeing familiar themes appear in maternity investigations can be difficult. You may be wondering whether the concerns identified nationally were also present during your own care.

 

Common questions families ask

You may be wondering: 

  • Were concerns about my baby recognised quickly enough? 
  • Should a senior clinician have been involved sooner? 
  • Were my concerns listened to? 
  • Could different decisions have prevented harm? 

These are the same questions our specialists work through when we review your records. If you’re not sure where to start, we’ll help you find the answers. 

Does a national review mean negligence occurred in my case?

No. National investigations look at wider patterns and themes across maternity services.

Even where a review identifies concerns at a hospital or trust, each family’s experience must be considered individually. We’d need to review your medical records to answer that.

A national review can show us where to look, but it can’t prove what happened in your case. For a claim, we need to show that the care you received fell below the expected standard, and that this caused harm that wouldn’t otherwise have happened. That comes from your own medical records and expert evidence.

There may be an individual investigation internally or by HSIB now MNSI into your own circumstances and this would be useful to see.

Why are family experiences so important?

Many maternity investigations have highlighted the importance of listening to women and families. Reviews have repeatedly found examples where concerns were raised but families felt they were not heard. 

Families often provide important information about what happened during pregnancy, labour and birth. Their experiences can help build a fuller understanding of whether the care you received met the standard we’d expect from a reasonably competent midwife or doctor. 

The issues I and my colleagues see are highlighted in this piece. It is very important that patients are able to tell their story and be listened to.
Trevor Ward Partner Solicitor and our Head of Birth Injury Unit

Are the lessons from maternity reviews leading to change?

The publication of new reviews is important because they help identify risks and opportunities for improvement. However, experts such as Donna Ockenden have argued that the focus must move beyond identifying problems towards ensuring recommendations are implemented and lead to meaningful change across maternity services. 

 

Trevor Ward, Partner Solicitor and our Head of Birth Injury Unit, shares:  “ I have been conducting investigations into birth injury claims for decades. The issues I and my colleagues see are highlighted in this piece. It is very important that patients are able to tell their story and be listened to. It is for the lawyers to then investigate whether that story matches allegations of breach of duty of care and causation of an avoidable injury. Adequate staffing, adequate support, escalation and importantly listening to mothers is an extremely important aspect of the care that people are entitled to receive.”

What does this mean if your family has been affected?

If your child suffered a birth injury, national reviews can provide useful context about the wider issues affecting maternity services. However, they cannot answer whether appropriate care was provided in your individual case. 

That requires a detailed review of what happened during your birth.  We review your medical records and ask independent medical experts to assess the decisions made. 

Understanding whether there has been a breach in the legal duty of care is only one part of the process. We also need to show causation. This means that not only was there a breach of duty, but this breach caused your baby’s health to worsen. We’d need to show that better care would probably have led to a different outcome for your baby. Our solicitors and independent medical experts look at both. 

What should you do if you have concerns about your maternity care?

If you’re worried about the care you received, you don’t need to have all the answers before speaking to us. Our specialist birth injury team are here to listen to your experiences and offer compassionate legal guidance. We are here to advise you of your legal options and support you in your next steps. We’ll listen, review your records and explain whether you may have a claim. Speak to our team today. 

A national team, here when you need us

With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.

See our locations

You're in safe hands

1/8
  • The Times Best Law Firm 2027

    THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM

  • Chambers Top Ranked Law Firm 2027

    CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM

  • Legal 500 Top Tier Firm 2027

    LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM

  • Armed Forces Covenant

    ARMED FORCES COVENANT

  • AvMA - Lawyers’ Service Member

    AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER

  • Head Injury Solicitor

    HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS

  • Spinal Injuries Association - Trusted Legal Partner

    SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

  • Child Brain Injury Trust - Trusted Legal Partner

    CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

Young woman looking thoughtfully through the window into the garden
LET'S GET YOU STARTED

Start your claim with confidence

Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.

Secret Link