Skip to main content
MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE

Securing client’s future following a delay in diagnosis of a spinal infection

Reviewed by Alex Haider Senior Associate
Last Updated

What happened?

Our client underwent spinal surgery at a private hospital in London to relieve back pain caused by a herniated disc. A week later, she developed further back pain. An MRI scan showed that the disc had herniated again, so she underwent another micro-discectomy.

Unfortunately, her pain continued and she returned to the hospital. Tests didn’t show another disc herniation, but they did show possible signs of an infection at the site of her surgery.

The surgeon carried out a washout of the operation site and sent tissue samples and wound swabs to the private hospital’s laboratory for testing. The preliminary laboratory report suggested a possible wound infection. However, the surgeon prescribed only a short course of oral antibiotics and discharged our client without arranging a follow-up appointment.

How did the delays affect her?

Our client’s back pain became worse, so she contacted the surgeon to explain her concerns. The surgeon didn’t think it was necessary to see her and advised her to contact the pain consultant who had originally referred her.

The pain consultant referred her to another spinal surgeon, who arranged a further MRI scan. This showed an infection at the original surgical site, and our client was referred back to her first surgeon.

She was admitted to hospital and started on intravenous antibiotics. A CT-guided biopsy indicated a deep wound infection.

As a result of the infection, our client needed further spinal surgery to fuse her spine at the site of the original operation. It was accepted that the initial infection hadn’t been caused by negligence.

What went wrong with her care?

After obtaining independent expert evidence from a professor of spinal surgery and a consultant microbiologist, Fletchers pursued a claim against the private surgeon and the private company providing the laboratory services.

The claim alleged that the surgeon hadn’t made sure the tissue samples and wound swabs were properly investigated by the laboratory. It was also alleged that the antibiotics prescribed weren’t appropriate to treat the infection and that he hadn’t arranged to review our client after she completed the course.

The laboratory was also alleged to have failed to properly analyse the tissue samples and swabs. The claim argued that, if the samples had been properly analysed, the results would have been passed to the surgeon so he could take the necessary steps to treat the infection.

It was also alleged that the spinal fusion put extra strain on the vertebrae immediately above the fused area, resulting in the need for further micro-discectomy procedures.

The surgeon denied all allegations of negligence. The laboratory admitted that it hadn’t properly analysed or reported on the samples, but didn’t admit that its failings had caused the harm.

A message from the lawyer

“The case highlights how a lack of effective communication between clinicians and support services, particularly in private healthcare where (unlike in the NHS) there are often several independent companies providing services, can result in disastrous consequences for patients”

Alex Haider

Senior Associate

What was the outcome?

Court proceedings were issued and the case was listed for a five-day trial in the High Court.

The parties held a joint settlement meeting to try to reach an agreement before the trial. Although they couldn’t agree a settlement at that meeting, they agreed one worth more than £460,000 shortly afterwards.

Our awards

1/8
  • The Times Best Law Firm 2027

    THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM

  • Chambers Top Ranked Law Firm 2027

    CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM

  • Legal 500 Top Tier Firm 2027

    LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM

  • Armed Forces Covenant

    ARMED FORCES COVENANT

  • AvMA - Lawyers’ Service Member

    AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER

  • Head Injury Solicitor

    HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS

  • Spinal Injuries Association - Trusted Legal Partner

    SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

  • Child Brain Injury Trust - Trusted Legal Partner

    CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

Young woman looking thoughtfully through the window into the garden
LET'S GET YOU STARTED

Start your claim with confidence

Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.

Secret Link