Compensation secured for mother of stillborn baby
After mistakes during her antenatal care led to the preventable death of her baby, our client pursued a medical negligence claim. Dr Mala Sidebottom secured a five-figure settlement which helped bring a difficult chapter to a close.
In this client story, we discuss:
- Concerns around monitoring fetal growth during pregnancy
- The circumstances leading to the stillbirth of our client’s baby
- The hospital trust’s response and admissions
- Expert evidence obtained during the claim
- The settlement secured for our client
Concerns raised during antenatal care
Our client discovered she was pregnant around 28 weeks into her pregnancy with her third child and attended her booking visit at Croydon University Hospital. She had her first scan around four weeks later, after which her pregnancy was estimated to be 30+5 weeks gestation.
Four weeks later, our client attended the antenatal clinic and saw an obstetric registrar. The registrar recorded a fundal height, a measure of the size of the uterus, of 30cm despite noting that our client was 34+5 weeks gestation. Although the fundal height should roughly correspond with the number of weeks of pregnancy, the registrar recorded growth as normal.
When concerns became more serious
Just over two weeks later, our client experienced contractions and a “show”. She contacted the labour ward and was advised to wait until the following morning. When she attended the labour ward the next day, she was examined by a midwife and an obstetrician. Medical staff were unable to locate the baby’s heart rate and confirmed an intrauterine death.
A post-mortem examination confirmed the intrauterine death of a growth-restricted baby boy, with death having occurred at least one week before delivery. The examination also identified a chromosomal abnormality.
The trust accepted mistakes were made
Our client submitted a letter of complaint to the hospital trust. In its response, the trust acknowledged that mistakes had been made. It accepted that a second scan would have shown that the baby was not growing properly and that our client’s care could then have been managed differently.
The trust apologised for the circumstances surrounding the loss and introduced a policy of routinely re-scanning women who book after 24 weeks of pregnancy. It stated that this approach would provide greater confidence in assessing both gestation and fetal growth.
A comment from their solicitor
“No amount of compensation can bring back our client's baby and she has to live with this knowledge every day. However, I am pleased that she has finally been able to bring an end to the litigation process.”
Mala Sidebottom
Partner and Medical negligence solicitor
Challenging the trust's position
A Letter of Claim was sent to the trust. Despite its earlier admissions, the trust later denied that the mistakes had affected the outcome. It argued that our client’s late booking appointment, together with smoking early in pregnancy, contributed to events. The trust also maintained that the chromosomal abnormality played a role.
To challenge this position, Dr Mala Sidebottom obtained expert evidence from a geneticist. The expert concluded there was no reason to believe the baby faced a risk of neonatal death because of the chromosomal abnormality. Further expert obstetric evidence supported the position that the baby’s death would have been avoided had appropriate ultrasound scanning taken place.
Achieving an outcome for our client
The case settled in October 2015 for a five-figure sum.
Reflecting on the outcome, our client praised the support she received throughout the claim. She said that Dr Mala Sidebottom explained complex medical issues clearly, kept her updated on progress and worked persistently to move the case forward.
Client comment:
“It is a shame it has taken this long and whilst no amount of money will bring my baby back, at least I can put it all to rest now. I would in particular like to thank Mala, who was very kind and understanding of my case. She explained all the medical jargon so I was comfortable knowing what it meant. She was conscientious about keeping me up-to-date on all progress and how the case was going. She was also very persistent in chasing the opponents to try and move my case forward as quickly as possible. I would recommend her to anyone.”
More like this
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.