Occupiers’ liability explained: key cases and legal principles
Occupiers' liability law has been shaped by a number of significant court decisions over the years. In this guide, Matthew Tuff reviews some of the key cases and the legal principles that continue to influence occupiers' liability claims today.
In this guide we discuss:
- The legislation that governs occupiers’ liability
- The duty occupiers owe to visitors
- When occupiers may owe a duty to trespassers
- Key occupiers’ liability cases
- What the courts consider when deciding liability
Understanding the legislation behind occupiers' liability
In this review, Matthew Tuff highlights some of the occupiers’ liability cases that have helped shape how the courts approach claims today.
Before looking at those cases, it is worth taking a quick look at the legislation behind them.
The liability of an occupier is governed by two key pieces of legislation:
The Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957
The Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984
These Acts set out the circumstances in which an occupier may be responsible when someone suffers an injury on their premises.
Key occupiers' liability facts
- Visitors Protected under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957
- Trespassers May be protected under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1984
- Reasonable care Courts consider whether reasonable steps were taken to keep people safe
What duty does an occupier owe visitors?
Section 2 of the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957 states that occupiers owe visitors a “common duty of care”.
In simple terms, this means taking reasonable care to ensure visitors are reasonably safe when using the premises for the purposes for which they are invited or permitted to be there.
The law recognises that every situation is different. Whether an occupier has met their duty will depend on the circumstances of each case.
What duty is owed to trespassers?
The Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984 deals with people who are not lawful visitors.
An occupier may owe a duty where:
- They are aware of a danger or have reasonable grounds to believe it exists
- They know someone may come into the vicinity of that danger
- It is reasonable to offer some protection against the risk
The duty is to take reasonable care to ensure the trespasser does not suffer injury because of the danger.
How do courts assess occupiers' liability?
Many occupiers’ liability cases are decided by balancing a number of competing factors. These can include how obvious a risk was, how likely it was to cause injury, the seriousness of the potential harm, the cost of preventative measures, and the wider impact those measures may have.
The cases below show how the courts have applied those principles in practice.
Some of the most useful and interesting occupiers' liability cases in recent years have helped shape how the courts approach claims today.
Cases where the occupier was not held responsible
These cases show that occupiers are not automatically responsible when someone is injured on their premises. The courts will often consider whether the risk was obvious and whether the injured person chose to take that risk.
Tomlinson v Congleton BC
The claimant suffered a life-changing spinal injury after diving into a shallow lake in a country park.
The court found the council was not responsible for the injury. Swimming in the lake was prohibited and warning signs were clearly displayed. The court decided that the injury resulted from the claimant’s decision to dive into shallow water, rather than from any danger created by the premises themselves.
This case helped establish an important principle: occupiers will rarely be expected to protect people from risks that are obvious and willingly accepted.
Geary v JD Wetherspoon
In this case, the claimant attempted to slide down a bannister in a pub before falling and fracturing her spine.
The court found there was nothing unsafe about the staircase itself. Instead, the risk arose from the claimant’s decision to slide down the bannister.
Following the approach taken in Tomlinson, the court concluded that the occupier was not responsible for the injury.
Edwards v London Borough of Sutton
The claimant fell from a bridge with low parapets while pushing a bicycle through a park.
Although the court accepted that a bridge could potentially create a danger, it also considered the wider consequences of adding barriers to historic structures and the broader public benefit of allowing access to them.
The court concluded that occupiers are not required to warn people about dangers that are obvious and found no breach of duty.
Cook v Swansea City Council
This case involved a claimant who slipped on ice in an unmanned car park.
The court decided the risk of ice during cold weather was an obvious one. It also considered the practical difficulty and cost of gritting every unmanned car park.
As a result, the council was not found to be responsible for the accident.
Lewis v London Borough of Wandsworth
The claimant was struck by a cricket ball while walking alongside a cricket pitch in Battersea Park.
The court found the risk of such an accident was remote and that a warning sign would not have made a difference because it was clear a cricket match was taking place.
The claim was unsuccessful.
Cases where the occupier was held responsible
These cases show that occupiers can be held responsible where a danger is not obvious and reasonable steps could have been taken to reduce the risk.
English Heritage v Taylor
The claimant suffered a serious head injury after falling from a route near an elevated platform at Carisbrooke Castle.
The court found that the danger was not obvious to someone approaching from the route taken by the claimant. Unlike the cases above, this was not a risk that a visitor could reasonably be expected to recognise.
English Heritage was found to have breached its duty of care, although the claimant was also found to be partly responsible for the accident.
The White Lion Hotel v James
This case involved a hotel guest who fell from a low sash window.
The court found that a simple and inexpensive safety measure, a window restrictor, could have reduced the risk. The occupier had not carried out a proper risk assessment and failed to identify that danger.
The court concluded that the hotel had breached its duty of care, although the claimant was found to be contributorily negligent.
The court also confirmed that an obvious risk does not automatically remove liability. It remains one factor among several that courts will consider when deciding whether reasonable steps should have been taken.
A different position: public rights of way
McGeown v Northern Ireland Housing Executive
This case confirmed that people using a public right of way are not considered visitors under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957.
This means that if someone is injured on a path where a public right of way exists, a claim under the Occupiers’ Liability Acts is often unlikely to succeed.
What do these cases tell us?
These cases show that occupiers are not automatically responsible when someone is injured on their premises. Instead, the courts will look at the specific circumstances of each case and decide whether it was reasonable to expect the occupier to take steps to reduce the risk.
This often involves considering:
- How obvious the risk was
- How likely the risk was to cause an injury
- How serious the injury could be
- The cost and practicality of preventing the risk
- The wider impact of any preventative measures
The cases also show that occupiers are not usually expected to protect people from obvious risks or risks they have chosen to take voluntarily. However, where a danger is not obvious and reasonable steps could have been taken to reduce the risk, an occupier may be held responsible.
Where a public right of way exists, a claim under the Occupiers’ Liability Acts is unlikely to succeed.
While every case is different, these decisions show how the courts assess responsibility when someone is injured on another person’s property. If you have been injured due to unsafe premises, you can learn more about making a public liability claim and the support available.
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.