How social media can damage your personal injury claim
If you’re making a personal injury claim, what you share on social media could affect your case. This guide explains how posts can be used as evidence, why inconsistencies matter and what you can do to protect your claim.
Example of what this guide covers:
- How social media activity can affect your personal injury claim
- When seemingly innocent posts become evidence
- What disclosure obligations mean for your claim
- The risks of fundamental dishonesty and what the courts can decide
- How to protect your claim when using social media
How social media can affect your personal injury claim
Social media helps us stay connected with family and friends. It’s natural to want to share moments from your life, including how you’re getting on after an injury. But once you post something online, you may have little control over who sees it.
During a personal injury claim, you may attend hospital appointments, have medical assessments and take part in rehabilitation. What you might not realise is that insurers, defendants and their solicitors may also monitor your progress through social media.
If your accounts are public, or your posts can be accessed indirectly, photos and videos could be reviewed and used as evidence. This matters because the other side may use content they believe contradicts your reported injuries to challenge your claim.
Key information
Facts and highlights
- Social media posts can become evidence Photos and videos may be used to challenge reported injuries or limitations.
- Disclosure continues throughout a claim Relevant evidence must be disclosed during formal proceedings.
- Dishonesty can have serious consequences A court can dismiss a claim if it finds fundamental dishonesty.
When innocent posts become evidence
A photo of you walking along a beach or attending a social event may seem harmless. However, the defendant’s solicitors could examine it and argue that it doesn’t match the injuries or limitations you’ve described.
For example, if you’ve explained that an accident has limited your mobility, a video of you appearing physically active could be used to challenge the severity of your injury. The context matters, but inconsistencies can affect how others view your evidence.
The other side may look for material that appears to contradict your account of your injuries or recovery. This can be particularly important when they’re assessing the value of your claim or whether they accept responsibility.
Your duty to disclose relevant evidence
It’s understandable to question how your online activity could become part of a legal claim. However, once formal court proceedings begin, all parties have a legal duty to disclose relevant evidence. This includes evidence that supports your case and evidence that may count against it.
This duty doesn’t apply just once. It continues throughout the claim, so your social media activity may remain under scrutiny as your case progresses.
Being aware of this obligation can help you understand why online posts matter, even if you shared them casually or long before you realised they might be relevant.
Fundamental dishonesty and the consequences for your claim
If evidence suggests that someone has exaggerated their injuries or made a claim that isn’t genuine, the defendant may allege fundamental dishonesty. This can relate to who was responsible for the accident or the amount of compensation being claimed.
Examples include exaggerating the extent of an injury or giving misleading information about recovery. A court may also consider fabricated or manipulated evidence.
If a judge finds that a claimant has been fundamentally dishonest, the court can dismiss the entire claim and order them to pay significant legal costs. This is a serious outcome, so it’s important to understand how evidence may affect your case.
Case example: Greening-Steer v Ainge
In Grant Greening-Steer v Derek Ainge, the claimant suffered serious injuries in a motorcycle accident. Although the defendant admitted liability, disputes arose over the diagnosis and extent of the injuries, as well as whether the claimant had been fundamentally dishonest.
Under section 57 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, a court must dismiss a personal injury claim if it finds fundamental dishonesty, subject to the statutory exception where dismissing the claim would cause substantial injustice.
Mr Justice Ritchie noted that the claimant had made a substantial recovery years before the trial. The claimant received £378,420 in damages, compared with the £4,924,418 originally claimed. The case shows how questions about a claimant’s reported limitations and other available evidence can have a significant impact on compensation.
How to protect your claim on social media
You don’t need to stop using social media altogether, but it’s important to understand how your posts could be interpreted during a claim.
Check your privacy settings. Set your accounts to private. Many platforms default to public settings, so you may need to change them yourself.
Think carefully before posting. Be mindful of content about your injuries, recovery or physical activities. Consider whether the other side’s legal team could interpret a post differently from how you intended.
Don’t delete existing content. Removing posts that you think could be misunderstood may raise concerns that you’re trying to conceal evidence. It could also lead to allegations of fundamental dishonesty.
Protecting your claim while you focus on recovery
Social media posts can affect how others assess your injuries and your account of recovery. What seems like an innocent update may be used to challenge your evidence, so it’s worth thinking carefully about what you share online while your claim is ongoing.
If you’re worried about how your social media activity could affect your case, you don’t have to work through the legal issues alone. Fletchers’ personal injury specialists can explain the claims process and help you understand your options.
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.