Skip to main content
PERSONAL INJURY

Client attacked in pub wins £500,000 brain injury compensation, the maximum award under the CICA scheme

Pub assault leaves our client with a severe traumatic brain injury

Our client was just 16 when he was punched in the head by an adult male in a local pub. The assault caused a severe traumatic brain injury, leaving him with significant physical and mental impairment and substantial ongoing care needs. Our specialists challenged an initial decision by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) to deny liability and ultimately secured the maximum award available under the scheme.

Case summary

  • Our client suffered a severe traumatic brain injury after being punched in the head at the age of 16.
  • The CICA initially denied liability, but this decision was successfully challenged at a tribunal.
  • Our client received the maximum CICA award of £500,000.

A single punch caused life-changing injuries

Our client was 16 when an adult male punched him in the head at a local pub. The attack caused a severe traumatic brain injury.

The consequences were significant. Our client was left with physical and mental impairment and will never be able to earn a living. He required substantial rehabilitation and has ongoing care needs, with input from the local authority.

Supporting our client beyond the compensation claim

The legal work involved more than pursuing compensation. Our specialists provided advice and support to our client’s family as they dealt with a catastrophic change in lifestyle.

We were also able to act as a deputy in our client’s affairs and provide help with wider legal matters. This included applying to appoint deputies through the Court of Protection. Our specialists also helped ensure our client could access rehabilitation services and information about practical support, including disability aids.

Challenging the CICA’s decision

The CICA initially denied liability because of allegations that our client had been fighting with the man who assaulted him.

Our specialists challenged that decision. The evidence was that what had happened before the assault was no more than friendly horseplay. We argued that the subsequent assault by an adult on our client, who was still a child, could not be treated in the same way.

The dispute went before a tribunal, which found in our client’s favour. This meant his claim could proceed and the extent of his injuries and long-term needs could be considered.

A single punch can lead to lifelong disabilities and dependence

“This case highlights the simplicity with which a serious brain injury can occur. A single punch can lead to lifelong disabilities and dependence.”

Damian Horan

Senior Partner

Building the medical evidence

Our specialists obtained extensive expert medical evidence to support the value of the claim. This included reports from a consultant neurologist, consultant neuropsychiatrist, consultant neuro-ophthalmologist, consultant in neurorehabilitation and a care expert who was an occupational therapist.

The assessment also needed to take account of our client’s pre-existing condition. Before the attack, he had already been categorised within the Asperger’s disorder spectrum. This ongoing condition therefore had to be considered when determining an appropriate level of compensation.

Securing the maximum £500,000 CICA award

Once the expert evidence and an appropriate schedule of loss had been provided, the CICA accepted that our client was eligible for the maximum award available under the scheme, £500,000.

The award reflected the severity of our client’s brain injury and its lasting consequences, including his inability to earn a living and his substantial ongoing care needs.

Damian Horan said:

“This case was complicated by the assertion by CICA that the client was in fact the aggressor, but we are happy that justice has been served and the compensation won will allow our client and their family to get the help they need in the future.”

The outcome followed a successful challenge to the CICA’s original decision and detailed expert evidence establishing the impact of our client’s injuries. Most importantly, the compensation would help our client and his family access the support they need for the future.

A national team, here when you need us

With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.

See our locations

You're in safe hands

1/8
  • The Times Best Law Firm 2027

    THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM

  • Chambers Top Ranked Law Firm 2027

    CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM

  • Legal 500 Top Tier Firm 2027

    LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM

  • Armed Forces Covenant

    ARMED FORCES COVENANT

  • AvMA - Lawyers’ Service Member

    AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER

  • Head Injury Solicitor

    HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS

  • Spinal Injuries Association - Trusted Legal Partner

    SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

  • Child Brain Injury Trust - Trusted Legal Partner

    CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

Young woman looking thoughtfully through the window into the garden
LET'S GET YOU STARTED

Start your claim with confidence

Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.

Secret Link