Defence of Automatism overcome to achieve a six figure settlement
Head-on collision claim settled after automatism defence challenged
Our client suffered a mild traumatic brain injury, multiple orthopaedic fractures and extensive scarring in a head-on collision. The other driver denied liability using the defence of automatism, arguing that an unexpected loss of consciousness meant they were not at fault. Our lawyers gathered detailed factual and medical evidence before the claim concluded with a six-figure settlement.
An example of a prompt summary
- Our client was injured when an oncoming car crossed onto her side of the road and caused a head-on collision.
- The other driver denied liability, relying on the defence of automatism.
- Our lawyers gathered witness, police and medical evidence and issued proceedings in the High Court.
- The claim concluded with a six-figure settlement.
A head-on collision caused serious injuries
Our client was driving when a car travelling towards her from the opposite direction crossed onto her side of the road. The vehicles collided head-on. It was not suggested that our client was at fault for the collision.
The collision left our client with a mild traumatic brain injury, multiple orthopaedic fractures and extensive scarring.
The other driver relied on the defence of automatism
Although our client was not alleged to have caused the collision, the other driver denied liability. They relied on a legal defence known as automatism.
Automatism can apply where an unforeseeable medical condition causes someone to lose control of their actions involuntarily. In this case, the other driver argued that they had lost consciousness because of “a diabetic condition and/or peripheral and/or autonomic neuropathy”. They maintained that they had taken reasonable care to make sure they were fit to drive and had blacked out unexpectedly.
This was important because our client needed to establish that the other driver was at fault to recover compensation. If the automatism defence had succeeded, our client would have received no compensation.
Evidence from before the collision was important
Our experts needed evidence to examine how and why the other driver had lost consciousness. The court would also have needed to consider the credibility of the other driver’s account if the case proceeded.
One important piece of evidence came from an independent witness who had been travelling behind the other driver. The witness said the car had already strayed across the road before the collision. Our client’s case was that this should have put the other driver on notice that something was wrong.
Our lawyers interviewed witnesses to the collision and the police officers who attended. This helped establish the factual circumstances surrounding the crash.
In our client's own words
“They were patient, helpful and unwaveringly knowledgeable throughout the whole process.”
Client
Building the medical evidence
Our lawyers sought disclosure of the other driver’s complete medical records. This allowed the legal team to investigate the automatism defence and consider the circumstances in which the other driver had lost control.
At the same time, our specialists gathered medical evidence about our client’s injuries and their effect on her life. Experts were approached in several disciplines, including neuroradiology, neurology, neuropsychiatry, neuropsychology, orthopaedics and plastic surgery.
Statements were also taken from people who knew our client and could explain how she had been affected. Together, this evidence helped our lawyers assess the value of her claim.
Taking the claim to the High Court
The other driver continued to deny liability and relied on automatism. To move the claim forward, our client issued proceedings in the High Court in London, seeking a split trial to determine fault.
At the same time, our lawyers presented the medical evidence gathered for our client and invited the other side to attend a Joint Settlement Meeting to explore whether the claim could be resolved.
The other side agreed to attend. Although they continued to deny liability, negotiations took place to try to reach an appropriate settlement.
A six-figure settlement for our client
The negotiations resulted in a six-figure settlement for our client despite the other driver’s continued denial of liability.
For our client, the settlement was about more than the conclusion of a complex legal claim. In her own words, the legal team had secured “a very good settlement for me to help me in my future”.
The case required our lawyers to investigate the circumstances of the collision, scrutinise the automatism defence and gather evidence across several medical disciplines. It also meant progressing the case towards a determination of fault while continuing to explore whether an agreed resolution could be reached.
Reflecting on the claim, our client said:
“Matthew Claxson and Olivia Smith have been the most fantastic support throughout my long major trauma claim and secured a very good settlement for me to help me in my future. From my very first phone call when I didn’t have a clue what I was even really asking for help with, they made me feel cared for and not stupid for not knowing what I needed; they were patient, helpful and unwaveringly knowledgeable throughout the whole process. Matthew came to visit me in person very soon after I first contacted them, he didn’t judge me in my very weak and vulnerable state of recovery and he got the ball rolling quickly on the lengthy process, always keeping me informed at every development, always there to answer any queries I had and always listening to, and reassuring me, on all my worries. From having the knowledge and unquestionable skill to guide me through the entire process, to always making me feel cared about and supported in getting the best outcome for my future, to building the most amazing team of experts for my case, Matthew and Olivia are worth their weight in gold. I couldn’t have asked for better support throughout the worst time in my life, and would recommend them to anyone who needs their unfaltering pillar of strength through theirs.”
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.