Skip to main content
NEWS

Families sign our open letter calling for action on NHS data breaches

Families devastated by NHS data breaches have signed an open letter to government ministers and health bosses calling on them to do more to crack down on staff who snoop. The letter penned by Fletchers Solicitors and co-signed by victims of multiple atrocities; from the Southport and Nottingham attacks to the NHS maternity scandals.

Key takeaways:

  • Who is the letter to
  • What does it aim to achieve
  • Who has signed the letter

Who is the letter to?

It calls on Health Secretary, Yvette Cooper, Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy and NHS Chief Executive, Jim Mackey to implement three measures signatories say will properly address the issue – adding that staff sanctions alone do not go far enough.

Nicola Ryan-Donnelly

Nicola on why we have sent the letter

“We have written and published this open letter because victims of NHS snooping have had enough.”

Nicola Ryan-Donnelly

Partner

What does the letter call for?

The letter calls for NHS staff to tick a mandatory declaration stating they have proper cause to access a record, and published independent audits of NHS Trust access records every quarter for a period of ten years.

Individuals affected by breaches have also called for the data watchdog, the Information Commission to recognise them as a victims so they have stronger powers to challenge breaches in future.

At present the IC acknowledges patients are affected but refers to the NHS Trust as the victim, as the data controller where records have been breached.

Who has signed the letter?

Over 30 families and individuals have signed the letter, including Southport survivors and the bereaved relatives of fatal Nottingham attack victims, Grace O’Malley Kumar and Ian Coates.

Alongside parents affected by various maternity scandals, campaigners such as Paula McGowan OBE and Tom McGowan have also signed, after their son Oliver’s records were breached multiple times years after his death.

The families have said they welcome the chance to meet with ministers and NHS bosses to discuss the issue further.

Nicola Ryan-Donnelly

Nicola on the impact this is having on families

“Every week in the media we are learning of a new breach into patients’ medical records by staff who have no legitimate cause to access them.”

Nicola Ryan-Donnelly

Partner

The letter

The Rt Hon Yvette Cooper MP, Secretary of State for Health and Social Care

The Rt Hon Lisa Nandy MP, Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport

Sir Jim Mackey, Chief Executive Officer, NHS England

5th November 2026

Dear all,

We write to you as individuals and organisations who have witnessed or experienced the devastating effects of medical data breaches. We urge you to take decisive and immediate action to prevent further breaches and safeguard patients’ personal information.  

In recent months, we have discovered repeated incidents of NHS staff snooping on some of the most vulnerable patients in our care system.

In the wake of the Nottingham attack, staff began prying while parents were still coming to terms with the deaths of their children. Other victims were still in hospital fighting for their lives when their records were breached.

Until this year, surviving children of the Southport attack had believed their details would be protected by court-ordered anonymity, safeguarding their privacy and protecting them from further distress. They and their families also believed their confidential medical records would be protected from inappropriate access. All those affected by the attack, including adult victims, survivors, and the families of those who died, should have been entitled to the same basic respect for their privacy and dignity. But the reality was that strangers, who had no direct involvement in their care, probed their most sensitive and personal information in a flagrant abuse of power.

The same deeply troubling behaviour has been repeated following numerous high-profile incidents involving vulnerable people. NHS staff breached the records of three-year-old Noah Woods, who drowned after disappearing near a Suffolk pond; William Chapman, who died after entering a tiger enclosure in Yorkshire; and a two-year-old boy, who was thrown into a crocodile pit at a zoo in Cambridge.

We have also seen a number of particularly disturbing targeted and personal attacks, where NHS staff have abused their position to access information about patients affected by rape and domestic abuse. In another deeply unsettling case, an NHS doctor at Addenbrooke’s Hospital used her position to access private information about her ex-boyfriend’s new partner and harass her family.

A recent press investigation found that more than 200 NHS staff had been dismissed and almost 2,000 others disciplined for inappropriately accessing patients’ medical records in the past five years alone.

And this problem is not exclusive to the NHS. The Ministry of Justice and HM Courts and Tribunals Service have both apologised for inappropriate access of sensitive, personal information belonging to the Southport victims.

While we recognise commitments have been made to dismiss or discipline NHS staff who snoop, we do not believe this goes far enough to prevent others falling victim to snooping in future.

We are calling for three things we believe could be implemented now, to instil a culture which will properly deter staff from inappropriately accessing records.

They are:

  1. Introduce a mandatory tick box to access records

Creating a declaration whereby NHS staff tick to explicitly say they have legitimate cause to access a record would serve as a deterrent and reminder that they should not be snooping.

  1. Compel the Information Commission to properly recognise victims of data breaches

The Information Commission currently recognises the organisation which stores the data (e.g. an NHS Trust) as the victim of any data breach – regardless of whether its own staff have breached that data. Patients should have clear, effective routes to obtain information about what data was accessed, when it was accessed, by whom, and what action has been taken in response. 

  1. Introduce quarterly independent audits of access records with published results

Introducing independent quarterly audits on NHS Trusts, with published results, for a period of ten years, would ensure complete transparency and accountability. Audits should identify patterns of inappropriate access, ensure that breaches are investigated and acted upon, and report on the action taken.

These breaches are deeply distressing and entirely preventable. We believe these three measures would make significant progress in tackling the problem and preventing further harm. 

We welcome the opportunity to meet with you and discuss this further.

Yours sincerely,

Fletchers Solicitors, on behalf of 22 children seriously harmed in the Southport attack

Leanne Lucas, survivor of the Southport attack

Heidi Liddle, survivor of the Southport attack

Jonathan Hayes, survivor of the Southport attack

Elaine Newton, partner of Nottingham attack victim Ian Coates

Dr Sanjoy Kumar MBE, parent of Nottingham attack victim Grace O’Malley-Kumar GM

Alice Topping and Pedro Jacob, victims of the Oxford maternity scandal

Rebecca Matthews, victim of the Oxford maternity scandal

Gary and Sarah Andrews, victims of the Nottingham maternity scandal

Jack and Sarah Hawkins, victims of the Nottingham maternity scandal  

Paula McGowan OBE and Tom McGowan, parents of Oliver McGowan

Kimberly Errington, victim of the Nottingham maternity scandal  

Angelina Sabatino, sister of Gemma Sabatino

Nicola Ryan-Donnelly, Partner at Fletchers Solicitors

Caroline Morris, Managing Director of Serious Injury at Fletchers Solicitors

Adrian Denson, Chief Legal Officer at Fletchers Solicitors

Peter Haden, Chief Executive Officer at Fletchers Solicitors

Nicola Brook, Broudie Jackson Turner solicitors

Simon Pillinger, Director of Pillinger Privacy and former NHS Information Governance Officer

Watch Nicola Ryan-Donnelly on Sky News discussing the letter

Nicola Ryan-Donnely on Sky News

A national team, here when you need us

With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.

See our locations

You're in safe hands

1/8
  • The Times Best Law Firm 2027

    THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM

  • Chambers Top Ranked Law Firm 2027

    CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM

  • Legal 500 Top Tier Firm 2027

    LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM

  • Armed Forces Covenant

    ARMED FORCES COVENANT

  • AvMA - Lawyers’ Service Member

    AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER

  • Head Injury Solicitor

    HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS

  • Spinal Injuries Association - Trusted Legal Partner

    SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

  • Child Brain Injury Trust - Trusted Legal Partner

    CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER

Young woman looking thoughtfully through the window into the garden
LET'S GET YOU STARTED

Start your claim with confidence

Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.

Secret Link