Damages secured for delayed diagnosis of a brain tumour
A delayed diagnosis of a brain tumour left a young client with irreversible damage, including the loss of sight in one eye. Despite the defendant denying liability, the team on the case secured a settlement with provisional damages, protecting the client’s right to seek further compensation if he loses sight in his remaining eye.
In this case...
- What happened: A delayed diagnosis of a brain tumour
- The impact of the tumour and delayed diagnosis
- The challenges of proving the claim
- How expert evidence helped build the case
- Reaching a settlement despite the defendant denying liability
- Provisional damages to protect the client’s future
What happened: A delayed diagnosis of a brain tumour
When the client was seven years old, he attended the defendant hospital’s paediatric department with concerning symptoms, including persistent headaches and vomiting in the early morning. Despite these warning signs, the hospital discharged him without a clear diagnosis or further investigation.
Several months later, his symptoms continued, and an MRI scan finally revealed a craniopharyngioma. This is a benign brain tumour that can still cause serious, life-changing harm. By the time doctors diagnosed it, the tumour had grown significantly.
The impact of the tumour and delayed diagnosis
By the time treatment began, the tumour had caused irreversible damage, including the loss of sight in one eye. The client underwent surgery followed by proton beam therapy, a relatively new treatment at the time.
Although the therapy successfully managed the tumour, its long-term effects remained uncertain. This added further uncertainty for the client and his family, as the full extent of the future impact was not yet clear.
The challenges of proving the claim
The defendant never admitted liability, making this a long and hard-fought claim. A central challenge was establishing whether the delay in diagnosis had caused the client’s loss of vision, or whether he would have experienced the same outcome even if doctors had acted sooner.
The team on the case needed to establish a clear link between the delay and the harm the client suffered. They also had to account for uncertainty about the long-term effects of proton beam therapy before they could fully assess the claim.
How expert evidence helped build the case
The team on the case instructed several expert witnesses to investigate how the tumour had grown and how its progression had affected the client’s vision. They examined the medical records, scan images and clinical timeline to build a detailed picture of what had happened.
This evidence helped the team address the defendant’s argument that the outcome might have been the same with an earlier diagnosis. Because the long-term effects of the treatment were still uncertain, the team also had to remain flexible as new medical information emerged.
Reaching a settlement despite the defendant denying liability
Despite the defendant’s refusal to admit liability, the team on the case prepared thoroughly for trial, ensuring the evidence was in place to support the claim. They also remained open to negotiations.
A settlement was reached just weeks before the trial date. This brought the claim to a resolution without the need for the case to proceed to trial.
Provisional damages to protect the client’s future
The client received a settlement that included provisional damages. This was a significant outcome because it protects his right to return to court to seek further compensation if he loses sight in his remaining eye.
The provision recognises the uncertainty surrounding the client’s future and provides a degree of financial protection if his condition worsens in this specific way. It also gives the client and his family greater security as they face an uncertain future.
Support with a medical negligence claim
If you or your child has suffered harm following a delayed diagnosis, you may have questions about what went wrong and what support is available. Our specialist medical negligence solicitors can help you understand your options and guide you through the claims process.
Visit our medical negligence claims page to find out how we can help. Contact us today to discuss your circumstances.
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.