Settlement for push-scooter rider following road traffic collision
Push-scooter rider secures settlement after serious knee injury in road traffic collision
Our client suffered a serious knee injury and psychological injuries when a driver collided with her as she travelled home from work on a push scooter. Our lawyers investigated the collision, challenged allegations that she was partly responsible and helped her access rehabilitation while building evidence about the lasting effects of her injuries. The claim ultimately concluded with a six-figure settlement.
Case summary
- Our client suffered a serious open right tibial plateau fracture and psychological injuries.
- The driver’s insurer accepted primary liability but alleged that our client had contributed to the collision.
- Following further investigation, medical evidence and negotiations, the claim settled for a six-figure sum.
A road traffic collision on her journey home
Our client was travelling home from work on a push scooter when the road traffic collision happened. She was riding on the pavement and passing the entrance to a petrol station when the driver of a Lexus collided with her.
The impact threw our client into the air. She landed on the bonnet of the car before falling to the ground. Paramedics treated her at the scene and she was taken by ambulance to the emergency department. Police also attended.
Our client suffered a serious open right tibial plateau fracture, an injury affecting the upper part of the shin bone at the knee joint, as well as psychological injuries.
Surgery and the impact of her knee injury
Our client underwent surgery to externally fix her right knee. Four days later, she had further surgery involving open reduction and internal fixation of the tibial plateau fracture.
She returned home two days after the second operation using crutches, with her right leg in a brace. Initially, she was advised not to put weight through the injured leg. Later that month, she was advised that she was likely to need a full knee replacement in 10 years and could begin partial weight bearing. Three months after surgery, she was gradually increasing the weight she could put through the leg and was weaned off the brace.
While she relied on crutches, our client needed significant help with everyday tasks she could not manage herself. Her partner and family provided this care and assistance.
Investigating who was responsible for the collision
Our lawyers contacted the police to establish the driver’s and vehicle’s details and approached the petrol station for CCTV footage of the collision. Once the driver and vehicle had been identified, the claim was notified to the driver’s insurer.
The insurer accepted primary liability but alleged that our client had contributed to the collision, initially without explaining why. When challenged, the insurer argued that our client had not been wearing a helmet and that her push scooter should be treated in the same way as a bicycle, meaning she should not have been using it on the pavement.
Our client strongly disputed these arguments, including the suggestion that she was required to wear a helmet while using a push scooter. Our lawyers continued investigating liability and provided the insurer with evidence including CCTV footage and the police report.
The driver was subsequently prosecuted for driving without due care and attention. He received a fine and six penalty points on his driving licence.
In our client's own words
“Matthew Claxson and Michelle Halsall were incredibly professional, prompt and calming during a very stressful time in my life when they were dealing with my accident case – I couldn’t recommend them highly enough.”
Client
Supporting our client's rehabilitation
Our client began NHS physiotherapy for her right knee, including exercises designed to strengthen her quadriceps and hamstrings. Her physiotherapist considered that a full recovery was unlikely because of the structural damage to her knee.
Our specialists instructed a case manager to progress additional rehabilitation. The insurer would not provide funding or engage with the rehabilitation process, so the case manager was instructed on a unilateral basis. Private therapies, aids and equipment were organised using deferred payment terms.
Our client was also worried about her job, which she had recently started. Despite these concerns and the effects of her injuries, she was motivated to take part in her rehabilitation and worked hard on her therapies with support from the rehabilitation team.
Building evidence about the long-term effects
To understand the likely value of the claim and the future impact of the injury, our lawyers obtained a medico-legal report from a consultant orthopaedic and trauma surgeon specialising in knee injuries.
Although the fracture had united well, the consultant concluded that our client would have permanent restrictions affecting activities including kneeling and squatting. She also had a high chance of requiring a knee replacement in the future, with consideration to be given to removing the metalwork in her knee. The development of secondary osteoarthritis in the injured knee was considered inevitable.
Assessing the impact of permanent scarring
The collision also left our client with significant scarring to her right leg and further scarring to her left lower leg and face. The scars were expected to be permanent.
Our client worked in the fashion industry, where the way she looked and carried herself was important to her. Our lawyers therefore obtained an opinion from a skin camouflage consultant. The consultant advised that the scars would be more sensitive to sunlight and would need protection. Recommendations were also provided for camouflage make-up and its likely annual cost over our client’s lifetime.
Challenging the proposed reduction in compensation
The insurer made a Part 36 offer proposing that liability should be divided 75:25. This would have treated our client as 25% responsible for her injuries and reduced the compensation she received by the same proportion.
Our client was understandably upset by the proposal because she held the driver wholly responsible for the collision. The insurer was unwilling to negotiate on liability, so our lawyers continued obtaining medico-legal evidence and finalising the evidence needed to progress the case.
Counsel was instructed to advise on the case. After obtaining counsel’s opinion, negotiations continued with the insurer on a monetary basis.
A six-figure settlement for our client
The claim ultimately concluded with a six-figure settlement based on the gross valuation of the claim.
The settlement followed detailed work to investigate the circumstances of the collision, challenge the insurer’s allegations, arrange additional rehabilitation and gather specialist evidence about the lasting consequences of our client’s knee injury and scarring.
Matthew Claxson conducted the claim with assistance from Michelle Halsall. Counsel was also instructed as the case progressed.
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.