Mian Munawar Shah Claims
If you or a loved one were treated by shoulder surgeon Mian Munawar Shah and suffered serious complications, you could make a medical negligence claim. Our specialist group action team is already acting for over 100 of his former patients, and we can help you understand your options.
-
-
TOP-RANKED LEGAL EXPERTS
CHAMBERS & LEGAL 500 -
NO WIN, NO FEE
Can I make a claim against Mian Munawar Shah?
You may be able to make a medical negligence claim if you were treated by Mr Shah and have concerns about the care you received. An independent review commissioned by Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust identified around 400 procedures of concern, with further patients recalled for assessment.
Mr Shah performed surgery between 2010 and 2020 at Spire Little Aston Hospital and Walsall Manor Hospital in the West Midlands. Because of the seriousness of the issues, Mr Shah has been placed under an interim order preventing him from carrying out any surgical procedures without direct supervision. These restrictions have been renewed repeatedly, most recently in September 2024. He has not practised at Spire Little Aston since 2020 and was dismissed by Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust in 2022.
The findings of the Trust’s review have raised serious concerns about the standard of care provided. You can read our full response to the Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust report for a clearer understanding of what the investigation uncovered and what it means for patients.
If you were contacted as part of the Trust’s review, or you are coming forward independently, it is worth speaking to a specialist. Our group action now includes more than 100 former patients of Mr Shah. If you are considering joining the action, contact our team. We will listen to your concerns, review what happened, and explain clearly whether you may have a claim.
Example of a claim against Mr Shah
A typical claim in this group action might involve a patient who underwent shoulder surgery performed by Mr Shah at Spire Little Aston. Instead of the improvements they were expecting, the patient is left with severe pain, reduced movement and ongoing difficulty using their arm. Some patients have required further corrective procedures, specialist rehabilitation or longterm pain management. If these complications arose because the surgery was carried out to a poor standard, or because the patient was not properly informed of the risks or alternative options, this could form the basis of a medical negligence claim against Mr Shah and the hospitals where he practised.
Related medical negligence claims we support
Expertise you can trust
- 9/10 clients would recommend us
- 8,500+ clients settled outcomes in last two years
- 400+ specialists in our Medical Negligence team
What compensation can help with
Recovering lost income and covering future care
Compensation in a group action is about giving each person the financial support they need to access further care, treatment and rehabilitation. It also helps address the practical and emotional impact of undergoing surgery that may not have been performed to the expected standard.
Many of Mr Shah’s former patients have experienced serious and lasting complications that have affected their ability to work, their independence and their quality of life. Compensation can help ease the financial pressure created by those injuries and support your recovery.
A successful medical negligence claim relating to Mr Shah may help fund:
- The cost of further corrective surgery or medical treatment
- Rehabilitation and physiotherapy
- Psychological support and counselling
- Loss of earnings, both past and future
- Ongoing care and support needs
- Travel and transport costs related to your treatment or recovery
Understanding the potential value
Every case is different, and the compensation available to you will reflect the severity of the harm you experienced, how it affects your daily life and independence, and whether you now need ongoing treatment or support. Although this is a group action, every case is assessed individually, and we will look carefully at your circumstances to understand the full impact on you. As this group action progresses, more information about case outcomes will be shared when available.
Understanding interim payments
Interim payments can provide breathing space while your claim is ongoing. If the evidence supports it, we may be able to secure early financial support to help with immediate costs such as treatment, rehabilitation or lost income. These payments are made before a final settlement and can ease some of the pressure you may be facing. Not everyone will be eligible, but where the circumstances allow, we will always explore this option. You should not have to wait until the very end of your claim to access the support you need.
Why choose Fletchers for your claim against Mian Munawar Shah?
Group action medical negligence cases require a firm with both the specialist expertise and the infrastructure to manage a case of this scale. At Fletchers, our medical negligence solicitors are already representing more than 100 former patients of Mr Shah. We understand the issues, we know the evidence, and we have the resources and experience to guide you towards the outcome you deserve.
Expertise you can rely on
- Already acting for over 100 former patients of Mr Shah, with deep knowledge of the issues involved
- Dedicated group action team with the infrastructure to support complex multi-client cases
- Ranked as a leading firm in clinical negligence by the Legal 500 Directory 2024
- Working directly with the legal teams of Mr Shah, Spire Little Aston and Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust on your behalf
- Hosted patient consultation meetings to keep clients informed and connected throughout the process
- Experts in both clinical negligence and serious personal injury, with a track record of complex, high-value cases
- No win, no fee, so you can pursue your claim without financial risk
You're not alone
We understand what you're going through.
Finding out that a surgeon who treated you has been the subject of a major independent review – and that hundreds of other patients have been affected – can feel deeply unsettling. You may have had years of dealing with ongoing pain and trying to make sense of why. You may feel let down or uncertain about what to do next.
We understand the challenges you’re facing, and we’re actively supporting other people in exactly this position. Some were contacted by the Trust as part of the review, while others came forward independently after suspecting something wasn’t right.
As part of a group action, you benefit from shared progress. When steps are taken that move the wider case forward, every client in the group benefits. You will be kept informed throughout, and you will always have a team you can turn to with questions.
You do not have to face this alone. Our team is ready to listen, and a free case assessment costs you nothing.
FAQs about claims against Mian Munawar Shah
What issues have been identified in relation to Mr Shah’s procedures?
Concerns about Mr Shah’s surgical practice were raised after an independent review commissioned by Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust identified around 400 procedures that required further scrutiny. The review highlighted issues with the standard of surgery performed, the outcomes experienced by patients and whether procedures were carried out appropriately.
Many former patients reported ongoing pain, reduced movement, nerverelated symptoms or the need for further corrective surgery. These complications raised questions about whether some procedures were performed to an acceptable standard and whether patients were given the information they needed to make informed decisions about their care.
How long does a group action medical negligence claim take?
Group action cases are more complex than individual claims, and the timescales reflect that. Because many clients are involved and the evidence base is substantial, these cases typically take longer to resolve than a straightforward personal injury claim. However, being part of a group can also create efficiencies – evidence gathered for one client may benefit others, and steps taken collectively can move things forward more quickly than acting alone. Our team will keep you updated on progress throughout and will give you honest guidance on timescales as the case develops.
What evidence do I need to make a claim?
You do not need to gather evidence yourself before contacting us. When you get in touch, our team will carry out a free case assessment to understand what happened to you. If we identify that you have a valid claim, we will begin collecting the evidence needed – including your medical records, details of your treatment and its outcomes, and independent expert medical opinion. We handle the process on your behalf, so you do not have to chase records or navigate the system alone.
Can I still claim if I was contacted by the trust as part of their review?
Yes. Being contacted by Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust as part of their independent review does not prevent you from making a legal claim for compensation. The trust’s review is a separate process from a legal claim. If you have received a letter or been recalled for further evaluation, we would encourage you to speak to us so we can explain your options and ensure your rights are protected.
What is a group action, and how does it work?
A group action – sometimes called a group litigation – allows a number of people who have been harmed in similar circumstances to bring their claims together. This can be more efficient and more powerful than individual claims. In this case, our team is already acting for over 100 former patients of Mr Shah. We work with each client individually to build their specific case, while also pursuing steps that benefit the group as a whole. If needed, we will apply for a Group Litigation Order from the court, which formally manages the claims together.
What support will I receive during my claim?
From your first contact with us, our team will take the time to understand your situation and explain the process clearly. We have expanded our group action team to include specialists Matthew Mitchell and Emma Edwards, working alongside partners Christian Beadell, Andrew Hesketh and Francesca Paul. We have already hosted consultation meetings for patients of Mr Shah to keep clients informed and connected. You will always have a team you can contact with questions, and we will keep you updated at every stage of your case.
How much will it cost me to make a claim?
We handle claims against Mr Shah on a no win, no fee basis. This means you do not pay our legal fees unless your claim is successful. We will explain the funding arrangement clearly before you commit to anything, so you understand exactly where you stand. A free case assessment is available to help you decide whether to proceed.
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You’re in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.