Claim for compensation following inadequate medical treatment
Our client suffered a rare and potentially life‑threatening shoulder injury during a school rugby match. Despite clear symptoms, the injury was missed at A&E and again at a virtual fracture clinic, leading to a long delay in diagnosis and treatment. This case shows how specialist support helped him navigate the impact of that delay and plan for his future.
In this client story, we discuss:
- The Injury our young client sustained during a school rugby match
- The missed diagnosis at A&E which changed his recovery
- Further missed opportunity at fracture clinic
- Delayed surgery and the long‑term impact for our young client
- The life‑changing consequences our client now has for his education and career
- Settlement and future support we reached for out client
Our young client’s injury and the missed opportunity to diagnose it
Our client sustained a rare but potentially fatal shoulder injury, a fracture and dislocation of the sternoclavicular joint, during a rugby match at school. This type of injury is an orthopaedic emergency because of its proximity to vital vascular and respiratory structures. He attended A&E with direct trauma to the clavicle and breathing difficulties.
Missed diagnosis at A&E
An x‑ray was taken, but the injury was missed and he was incorrectly diagnosed with a soft‑tissue injury. Independent medical opinion later confirmed it was indefensible to miss the injury given the history and clinical examination, which would have revealed marked abnormalities of the sternoclavicular joint. Our client should have been referred to a surgical consultant and had a CT scan within the hour. He required urgent surgery with cardiothoracic expertise. Instead, he was reassured and discharged from A&E without any follow‑up arranged or any analgesia.
Delayed diagnosis and its long‑term consequences
He attended a virtual fracture clinic the following week, where another opportunity to diagnose the injury was missed. After a difficult and painful journey, the injury was eventually diagnosed months later. He underwent a delayed chronic sternoclavicular joint stabilisation procedure, a delay of 72–77 days, which was only partially successful. By this point, bony healing had already taken place and it was too late to restore anatomic alignment. He has been left with a permanently dislocated joint and an altered appearance.
Life‑changing consequences for education and career
He was extremely outdoorsy and rugby was a particular passion. He had hoped for a manual or vocational career. Sadly, both his treating surgeon and the expert in the claim do not sanction a return to contact sports, which is life‑changing for him. He had to change his university degree and rethink his future career plans. Tasks above shoulder height are now managed with pain relief, and he will require assistance with such tasks as he gets older.
Settlement and future support
Natalie Hirst, a senior associate, secured a settlement after the Trust admitted some elements of the claim at an early stage. The compensation means he can plan for future surgery and won’t be left at a financial disadvantage as he continues his recovery.
Client testimonial:
“Natalie Hirst did her very best for us throughout the whole lengthy process. Her attention to detail was exceptional and she was very patient and helpful in obtaining all the information she needed from us, which was quite extensive. She researched our son’s injury and surgery and we feel she went over and above to achieve the best possible outcome for us. Thank you!”
Words from Solicitor Natalie Hirst:
“The Trust admitted some elements of the claim at an early stage which meant the claim was settled without the need to issue court proceedings. The compensation will enable our client to have future surgery and to ensure he is not at a financial disadvantage in the future. Like so many of our clients, his hope is that lessons have been learned and that such injuries are recognised promptly given the potentially drastic consequences of failing to do so.”
Words from their solicitor
“The compensation will enable our client to have future surgery and to ensure he is not at a financial disadvantage in the future.”
Natalie Hirst
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.