Was disability due to prematurity or negligence?
A significant settlement will help provide the lifelong care, therapies, support and accommodation our client requires. The claim arose after failings in antenatal care left her with severe neurological injuries following a premature birth.
In this client story, we discuss:
- The lifelong impact of our client’s disabilities
- Concerns surrounding her mother’s care before delivery
- Whether her injuries were caused by prematurity or negligence
- The challenges involved in securing accountability
- The support secured for her future
Securing lifelong support for our client
Our client was born at just 25 weeks’ gestation and suffered a severe neurological injury that resulted in lifelong physical and cognitive disabilities. At times, there were concerns that she might not survive.
Now aged 17, her day-to-day functioning remains equivalent to that of a two-year-old. She requires extensive support and will need specialist care, therapies and assistance throughout her life.
Following a claim represented by Paul Kingsley, the family secured a settlement that will help provide the long-term care, support and accommodation their daughter requires. Interim payments secured during the claim enabled the family to access case management services and additional support at home as the case progressed.
The compensation award includes a substantial lump sum together with annual payments for life. It will help ensure our client has access to the care, case management, therapies, equipment and housing support she requires throughout her lifetime.
Concerns during pregnancy
During her second trimester, our client’s mother attended hospital with abdominal pain. Despite remaining in hospital for three days, the risk of premature labour was not identified until shortly before she went into labour and our client was delivered prematurely.
It was only around 40 minutes before our client was born that her mother received a partial dose of corticosteroids. These medications are routinely used when premature labour is anticipated and can help reduce the risk of neurological injury and other complications associated with prematurity.
Was the injury caused by prematurity or negligence?
When our client’s family first sought legal advice, concerns centred on her neonatal care. However, independent expert evidence later supported a different claim. As with many complex birth injury claims, the key question became whether earlier intervention would have made a significant difference to the outcome.
The case focused on whether the risk of premature labour should have been recognised earlier and whether our client’s mother should have received a full course of corticosteroids before delivery.
While it was accepted that extreme prematurity carries a risk of neurological injury, the central question remained whether our client’s disabilities were caused by prematurity alone or whether earlier intervention would have made a significant difference to her outcome.
In her mother's own words
“This outcome gives us hope that our daughter will get the support and care required to make her life better”
Establishing what caused our client's injuries
Although the hospital accepted failings in care, it continued to dispute whether those failings were responsible for our client’s injuries.
The hospital’s position was that our client’s mother would only have received a partial dose of corticosteroids in any event and that her injuries would have occurred because of her extreme prematurity regardless of the care provided.
Following extensive expert evidence and legal scrutiny, the hospital eventually accepted that, with appropriate management, our client’s mother would have received a full course of steroids before delivery.
As discussions between medical experts progressed, significant agreement emerged that the severity of our client’s injuries would probably have been avoided with appropriate treatment. Expert evidence supported the position that earlier administration of corticosteroids would, on the balance of probabilities, have avoided the severity of the injury that led to her lifelong disabilities.
Achieving an outcome for our client and her family
After years of complex legal work, the hospital ultimately agreed to accept responsibility for 97.5% of our client’s overall condition.
Interim payments secured during the claim enabled the family to access case management services and additional support while the case progressed.
The final compensation settlement has now been approved by the Court and will provide funding for our client’s lifelong needs. This includes care, case management, therapies, equipment and appropriate housing support, helping ensure she can access the support she requires throughout her life.
The settlement provides long-term financial security for our client and her family and will help improve her quality of life for years to come.
The compensation award includes a substantial lump sum and annual payments for life, with a lifetime value estimated at £18.3 million.
In her mother’s own words
“After 17 years of pain, frustration and uncertainty, this victory feels like a long-awaited breath of fresh air. The journey has been difficult, but we thank God for this outcome which gives us hope that our daughter will get the support and care required to make her life better.
We want to express our deepest gratitude to the team led by Paul Kingsley, our leading counsel and the medical expert team for their unwavering dedication, compassion and expertise throughout the entire process. We hope this case raises awareness of the importance of appropriate antenatal review, and the benefit of administering antenatal steroids in cases of premature labour.”
A comment from their solicitor
“I am delighted at this outcome for our client and her family, who have remained focused on her wellbeing throughout this long-running and challenging claim. Although the hospital was not prepared to engage in early discussions about resolving the case, our client’s position strengthened considerably as the evidence developed. We are now confident of securing sufficient funding to meet her lifetime needs and provide the support she requires in the future.”
Paul Kingsley
Senior Associate, Fletchers
A national team, here when you need us
With offices across the UK, we’re never too far away, helping people access specialist advice and support wherever they are.
You're in safe hands
-
THE TIMES BEST LAW FIRM
-
CHAMBERS TOP RANKED LAW FIRM
-
LEGAL 500 TOP TIER FIRM
-
ARMED FORCES COVENANT
-
AVMA - LAWYERS’ SERVICE MEMBER
-
HEADWAY ACCREDITED SOLICITORS
-
SIA - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
-
CBIT - TRUSTED LEGAL PARTNER
Start your claim with confidence
Not sure where to start? We’ll listen, guide you, and give clear, honest advice on what to do next.